Car Insurance for New Drivers Ontario – G1 and G2
Save up to 20% on your first policy – Compare quotes from Ontario’s top insurers in minutes.
Why New Drivers Pay More for Car Insurance in Ontario
The reality: New drivers in Ontario face some of Canada’s highest insurance premiums. But understanding why can help you find better rates.
Insurance companies use statistical data showing that drivers under 25 with less than 3 years of experience are significantly more likely to be involved in accidents. This higher risk translates directly to higher premiums – but there are proven ways to reduce these costs.
Am I Considered a New Driver?
You’re classified as a “new driver” in Ontario if you meet any of these criteria:
Age-Based Classification
- Under 25 years old with limited driving experience
- Any age with less than 3 years of valid Ontario license history
License-Based Classification
- G1 License Holders: First stage requiring constant supervision by experienced driver
- G2 License Holders: Second stage allowing independent driving with some restrictions
- New G License Holders: Full license holders with less than 3 years experience
Residency-Based Classification
- New Immigrants: First-time insurance buyers in Ontario
- Inter-Provincial Movers: Relocating from other Canadian provinces
- Mature First-Time Drivers: Adults getting licensed for the first time
How Much Does New Driver Insurance Cost?
2025 Average Annual Premiums in Ontario
- New Drivers (G1/G2): $2,400 – $7,200 per year ($200-$600 monthly)
- Experienced Drivers: $1,500 – $2,500 per year
- Provincial Average: $2,006 annually ($167.67 monthly) according to FSRA (October 2024 data)
2025 Market Update: In Ontario, the average car insurance premium increased by 4.10% in 2025, continuing a multi-year trend of rising rates, with Kingston seeing the steepest increase at 14.73% year-over-year and Barrie at 13.78%.
What Affects Your Premium
| Factor | Impact on Cost | Money-Saving Tips |
|---|---|---|
| Age & Gender | Males under 25 pay most | Consider family discounts |
| Location | Toronto/Brampton: +50-75% | Compare suburban vs urban rates |
| Vehicle Type | Luxury/sports cars: +40-60% | Choose insurance-friendly models |
| Coverage Level | Full coverage: +25-35% | Optimize deductibles strategically |
| Driving Record | Clean record: -15-25% | Complete defensive driving courses |
Insurance for G1 and G2 Drivers
Understanding Ontario’s Graduated Driver Licensing (GDL) System
Ontario’s Graduated Driver Licensing (GDL) program, in place since 1994, addresses the fact that new drivers have the highest accident and fatality rates by providing a structured learning environment to build skills and experience.
G1 License Insurance Requirements
Mandatory Supervision Rules:
- Must be supervised by driver with 4+ years of G license experience and zero blood alcohol level
- Supervisor must sit in front passenger seat
- G1 drivers must maintain zero blood alcohol and zero THC at all times
- Cannot drive on 400-series highways, high-speed expressways, or between midnight and 5 a.m.
- Usually covered under parent’s/guardian’s policy at no extra cost
Insurance Considerations:
- A G1 driver cannot be the primary driver on a policy, even if they own the vehicle. You need a parent or guardian (G2 minimum) to be the primary driver
- Failure to meet supervision requirements can result in claim denial
- Always notify your insurer immediately when obtaining your G1
G2 License Insurance Requirements
Enhanced Privileges After 12+ Months:
- G2 drivers can drive independently on all Ontario roads at any time without supervision
- Must maintain zero blood alcohol level and zero THC at all times
- Must ensure all passengers wear seat belts
- Must hold G2 for minimum 12 months before taking final G road test (or 8 months with approved driver training)
Special Restrictions for Drivers 19 and Under:
- Between midnight and 5 a.m.: can only have one passenger 19 or under (unless family members)
Coverage Options:
- Can purchase own policy if you own the vehicle
- Can remain on family policy as listed driver
- Must have mandatory coverage: Liability, Accident Benefits, Uninsured Motorist
Cost Consideration: Insurance for a new G2 driver in Ontario typically ranges from $200 to $600 per month, representing 20-30% less than G1 drivers but still facing new driver premiums.
New Drivers from Other Countries
Getting Credit for International Experience
Documentation Required (Government of Ontario Standards):
- For more than 12 months’ experience, applicants must provide an authenticated letter from their embassy/consulate or licensing agency in English or French
- Official letter from foreign licensing authority must be authentic
- English or French translation (notarized if not originally in these languages)
- Authentication from issuing government agency
Experience Recognition by Region:
- North American Experience: Often fully recognized with proper documentation
- International Experience: Maximum 3 years credit – “A full 24 months of Ontario and foreign experience is required prior to attempting their G2 exit test”
- Varies by Insurer: Some companies more flexible than others – using an insurance broker helps locate companies that will honour international driving history
Important Note: Only experience within recent years is typically considered valid for insurance purposes.
7 Proven Ways to Lower Your New Driver Insurance
1. Choose the Right Vehicle
Save 15-30%
Best Options for New Drivers:
- Compact sedans (Honda Civic, Toyota Corolla)
- Avoid luxury, sports, or high-theft vehicles
- Check insurance costs before buying
2. Complete Driver Training
Save up to 15%
- MTO-recognized driving schools only
- Certificate must be from approved provider
- Savings apply for 3+ years
3. Use Telematics/Usage-Based Insurance
Save up to 20%
How it works:
- Small device monitors driving habits
- Rewards safe driving behaviors
- Potential savings: $600-1,200 annually
4. Optimize Your Deductibles
Save 10-15%
- Higher deductible = Lower premium
- Balance affordability with potential out-of-pocket costs
- Consider separate deductibles for comprehensive vs collision
5. Pay Annually Instead of Monthly
Save 2-3%
- Eliminates 1.3% monthly payment fee
- Saves $40-180 per year on average premiums
6. Bundle with Family Policies
Save 5-15%
- Multi-vehicle discounts
- Multi-policy discounts (home + auto)
- Family claim-free bonuses
7. Consider Location Strategy
Save 25-75%
- Suburban vs urban postal codes
- Example: Tillsonburg vs Toronto = 75% savings
- Factor in commute costs vs insurance savings
High-Risk New Drivers: What You Need to Know
If you have traffic violations or accidents, you may need specialized coverage:
Standard Market Eligibility Lost With
- Criminal driving convictions (impaired, dangerous driving)
- Multiple major violations in 3 years
- At-fault accident + multiple minor violations
- License suspensions or cancellations for non-payment
Alternative Coverage Options
- High-Risk Insurance: Specialized insurers for challenging records
- Facility Association: Last-resort coverage mandated by law
- Broker Assistance: Essential for finding coverage options
Compare Ontario New Driver Auto Insurance Quotes
We specialize in car insurance for new drivers in Ontario. Whether you’re coming from another province in Canada, or out-of-country, we have an insurance solution for you. With access to the top insurance providers in Canada, we can help you compare quotes for the cheapest and best prices. Call, text or email us today for a comprehensive quotation.
2025 Top-Rated Insurance Companies for New Drivers
2025 Market Factors Affecting Rates
Current Rate Increases:
- In Ontario, the average car insurance premium increased by 4.10% in 2025, continuing a multi-year trend of rising rates
- Kingston saw the steepest increase in the province, with average premiums up 14.73% year-over-year. Other notable car insurance price increases happened in Barrie (+13.78%)
Contributing Factors to Rising Costs:
- Car insurance premiums are expected to keep climbing in 2024, with inflation and rampant auto theft driving the charge
- Increased repair costs due to inflation
- Rising vehicle theft rates affecting comprehensive coverage costs
- Supply chain issues impacting parts availability and costs
Based on recent industry analysis, here are the leading insurers for young and new drivers in Ontario:
Best Overall Rates by Demographics
- Female Drivers 25 and Under: Commonwell Insurance offers the most competitive rates
- Male Drivers 25 and Under: Intact Insurance provides the best average rates
- G2 Male Drivers: Travelers Insurance showed the most competitive pricing
- G2 Female Drivers: Intact Insurance offered the best rates
Key Considerations When Choosing
Remember that the “best” car insurance company is more than just price. Consider customer service, claims handling, coverage options, and financial stability alongside premium costs.
Telematics for New Drivers: Pros & Cons
Advantages
- Up to 20% premium savings
- Immediate feedback on driving habits
- Helps develop safer driving patterns
- Easy to install and use
Disadvantages
- Privacy concerns about monitoring
- Potential premium increases for poor driving
- Limited availability with some insurers
- May not suit all driving patterns
Get Your Free Quote Today
Ready to save on new driver insurance? Our licensed brokers have access to Ontario’s top insurers and can find you the best rates.
Why Choose Our Service
- Access to 20+ Top Insurers – Compare rates instantly
- New Driver Specialists – We understand your unique needs
- No Hidden Fees – Free quotes and ongoing support
- Fast Processing – Get covered in 24 hours or less
Contact Methods
- Call: Get instant quotes over the phone
- Text: Quick questions and follow-ups
- Email: Detailed quotes and documentation
- Online Chat: Real-time assistance
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need my own policy as a G2 driver?
Only if you’re the registered owner of the vehicle. Once you get your G2, you can be listed either as a principal operator or occasional driver under someone else’s policy, depending on how many vehicles and drivers there are in the household and how you use the vehicle.
How long am I considered a “new driver”?
Typically 3 years from your first Ontario license, though age (under 25) can extend this classification. The graduated licensing system requires drivers to progress through three stages (G1, G2, and G), meeting specific requirements at each level.
What are the key restrictions for G1 and G2 drivers?
G1: Must maintain zero blood alcohol and zero THC, require supervision by fully licensed driver with 4+ years experience, cannot drive on 400-series highways or between midnight and 5 a.m.
G2: Must maintain zero blood alcohol and zero THC, can drive independently on all Ontario roads at any time. Drivers 19 and under have additional restrictions: between midnight and 5 a.m., can only have one passenger 19 or under (unless family members).
Can I get insurance with a G1 license only?
It’s on a case-by-case situation, and there must be a person in the household with a G2 or G license.
How does the 12-month probationary period work?
You must hold your G2 license for minimum 12 months before taking the final G road test (or 8 months if you complete an approved driver training course). During this time, you have full driving privileges but must maintain zero blood alcohol/THC and follow passenger restrictions if you’re 19 or under.
Will my international driving experience help?
Yes, if properly documented. North American experience is most readily accepted; international experience may receive up to 3 years credit.
What if I can’t get standard insurance?
High-risk or Facility Association coverage is available for all drivers, though at higher cost.
Ready to Start Saving?
Don’t overpay for new driver insurance. Get your personalized quote today and discover how much you can save.
GET YOUR FREE QUOTE NOW – Compare rates from 20+ insurers in minutes.
Licensed insurance brokers available 7 days a week to help you find the perfect coverage at the best price.
Last updated: July 2025 | Ontario insurance regulations and rates subject to change