Does "no-fault" mean my insurance rates won't go up after an accident?

No, this is a common misconception. "No-fault" refers only to the process of how you claim benefits and get your vehicle repaired—from your own insurer. If you are determined to be at-fault for an accident, your premiums will very likely increase at your next policy renewal.

Is DCPD the same as Collision coverage?

No, they cover different situations. DCPD covers damage to your vehicle only when you are not at fault in a collision with another insured vehicle in Ontario. Optional Collision coverage applies when you are at fault in an accident, and it also covers damage from single-vehicle accidents (e.g., hitting a guardrail) and damages from a hit-and-run where the at-fault driver is unidentified.

How does no-fault insurance apply if I hit a deer or slide into a ditch?

This depends on the type of single-vehicle accident. Damage from hitting an animal is specifically covered under optional Comprehensive coverage. Damage from other single-vehicle incidents, like sliding into a ditch or hitting a tree, is covered by optional Collision or All Perils coverage. In any of these cases, DCPD does not apply.

What happens to my DCPD coverage when I drive outside of Ontario?

DCPD rules are specific to accidents that occur within Ontario. When you drive elsewhere, the laws of that province or state apply. However, Ontario has reciprocity agreements with certain jurisdictions, such as the state of Michigan, which can affect how claims are handled. This is why having optional Collision coverage is crucial for robust protection when travelling.

Who actually determines my percentage of fault after an accident?

Your insurance adjuster determines your percentage of fault. They do this by applying Ontario's provincially legislated Fault Determination Rules , which outline how to assign fault in dozens of common accident scenarios. It is a standardized process, not an arbitrary decision.

What if I am hit by an uninsured driver?

If you are hit by a driver who is identified and confirmed to be uninsured, your damages would be covered under the mandatory Uninsured Automobile Coverage section of your policy, not DCPD. In Ontario, this coverage provides up to $25,000 for damages to your vehicle and its contents and is subject to a mandatory $300 deductible.

No-Fault Insurance Ontario Explained (2025): Your Guide to DCPD Coverage

No-fault insurance is a system that allows you to claim directly from your own insurance company for damages and injuries after an accident. This comprehensive guide from carinsuranceinontario.ca explains how the Direct Compensation Property Damage (DCPD) system works, and is updated for August 2025.

Key Takeaways

The “no-fault” system in Ontario is a misnomer; fault is always determined, but you deal with your own insurer for vehicle repairs.
The system replaced the old “tort” system in 1990 to provide faster compensation for injuries and damages.
DCPD is the portion of your policy that covers your vehicle damage in a not-at-fault accident, with three specific conditions.
You can still sue for pain and suffering or loss of income if your injuries meet a “serious and permanent impairment” threshold.
Removing DCPD coverage with the OPCF 49 endorsement means you permanently give up your legal right to sue the at-fault party for your vehicle damages.

What Is No-Fault Insurance and Why It Matters in Ontario?

The no-fault system replaced the old “tort” system in 1990, which relied on court-awarded compensation. Under the old system, claimants often faced lengthy wait times and legal battles to receive settlements. The no-fault system was implemented to make it easier and faster for a consumer to receive compensation for their damages or loss. It does not eliminate fault—it simply dictates that you deal with your own insurer to get your vehicle repaired and to access your accident benefits.

The Two Parts of No-Fault Insurance in Ontario

The no-fault system in Ontario is often a source of confusion because it covers two distinct types of coverage:

Direct Compensation Property Damage (DCPD): This is the portion of your policy that pays for the damage to your vehicle, its contents, and the loss of its use when you are found to be not at fault.
Statutory Accident Benefits (SABS): This is the mandatory portion of your policy that provides compensation for medical, rehabilitation, and other expenses if you or your passengers are injured in a car accident. These benefits are paid out regardless of who is at fault for the crash.

Benefits of No-Fault Insurance

The no-fault system was designed to improve the consumer experience. Key benefits include:

Faster Claims Processing: Your claim is managed directly by your own insurer, which streamlines the settlement process.
Simplified Claims Resolution: The process is non-adversarial, with settlements based on established rights and schedules rather rather than court decisions.
Reduced Legal Costs: With fewer disputes taken to court, legal fees and court costs are significantly reduced for both insurers and insured individuals.
Predictable Benefits: Benefits for bodily injury have been standardized, providing consistent coverage.

The Three Conditions for DCPD Coverage

For your DCPD coverage to apply to a not-at-fault accident, all three of the following conditions must be met:

Location: The accident must occur within the province of Ontario.
Fault: You must be wholly or partially not at fault.
Insurance: At least one other vehicle involved in the accident must have a valid Ontario auto insurance policy.

DCPD & Out-of-Province Drivers:

The Rules This is where the rules become complex, and a key point of confusion for many drivers. If you are in a not-at-fault accident in Ontario with a vehicle insured in another province or the USA, your DCPD coverage may not apply.

General Rule: DCPD does not apply when the at-fault vehicle is insured in provinces like Saskatchewan, British Columbia, or Manitoba, or in the USA.
The Exception: DCPD Undertaking: However, some specific insurers (including some in the USA like Geico) and states have what are known as “reciprocity agreements.” These insurers are “signatory to the DCPD Undertaking,” which legally binds them to the same DCPD rules.
Licensed Insurers: Furthermore, if an out-of-province insurer is licensed to write auto insurance in Ontario, they are also subject to DCPD rules.

The Ultimate Risk: You Give Up Your Right to Sue

If you choose to remove your DCPD coverage using the OPCF 49 endorsement and are involved in a not-at-fault accident, you permanently give up your legal right to sue the at-fault driver or their insurance company to recover the cost of your vehicle’s damages. For a small potential premium savings, you expose yourself to the full financial risk of a major repair bill with no legal recourse.

Can You Sue for Injuries Under No-Fault Insurance?

Yes, under certain circumstances. The no-fault system allows for legal action for injuries that meet a specific severity “threshold,” which means they must involve a “serious and permanent impairment of either physical or psychological function.” This includes suing for pain and suffering or for loss of income.

How Property Damages and Deductibles Work

No-fault insurance does not absolve you from responsibility. Your insurance company uses the Fault Determination Rules to assess each driver’s responsibility.

Not at Fault: DCPD coverage will be used for the percentage you are not at fault.
At Fault: Collision or All Perils coverage (if purchased) will be applied for the percentage you are at fault.

The following table and examples illustrate how varying degrees of fault influence the distribution of damages and the deductible you pay, assuming total damages of $10,000 and a $1,000 deductible for Collision coverage.

Fault %	DCPD	Collision or All Perils	Deductible –$1,000
100%	$0	$10,000	$1,000
75%	$2,500	$7,500	$750
50%	$5,000	$5,000	$500
25%	$7,500	$2,500	$250
0%	$10,000	$0	$0

Drawbacks of No-Fault Insurance

Despite its benefits, the no-fault system has some drawbacks:

Limited Legal Recourse: You can only sue for specific types of injuries that meet a high severity threshold.
Potential for Higher Premiums: Insurers may face higher claim frequencies, and fraud can increase costs, which can be passed on to consumers.
Reduced Incentive: Some argue that the system diminishes the incentive for drivers to be cautious, as they know their own insurance will cover their damages regardless of fault.

Frequently Asked Questions about DCPD & No-Fault Insurance

Does “no-fault” mean my insurance rates won’t go up after an accident?

No, this is a common misconception. “No-fault” refers only to the process of how you claim benefits and get your vehicle repaired—from your own insurer. If you are determined to be at-fault for an accident, your premiums will very likely increase at your next policy renewal.
Is DCPD the same as Collision coverage?

No, they cover different situations. DCPD covers damage to your vehicle only when you are not at fault in a collision with another insured vehicle in Ontario. Optional Collision coverage applies when you are at fault in an accident, and it also covers damage from single-vehicle accidents (e.g., hitting a guardrail) and damages from a hit-and-run where the at-fault driver is unidentified.
How does no-fault insurance apply if I hit a deer or slide into a ditch?

This depends on the type of single-vehicle accident. Damage from hitting an animal is specifically covered under optional Comprehensive coverage. Damage from other single-vehicle incidents, like sliding into a ditch or hitting a tree, is covered by optional Collision or All Perils coverage. In any of these cases, DCPD does not apply.
What happens to my DCPD coverage when I drive outside of Ontario?

DCPD rules are specific to accidents that occur within Ontario. When you drive elsewhere, the laws of that province or state apply. However, Ontario has reciprocity agreements with certain jurisdictions, such as the state of Michigan, which can affect how claims are handled. This is why having optional Collision coverage is crucial for robust protection when travelling.
Who actually determines my percentage of fault after an accident?

Your insurance adjuster determines your percentage of fault. They do this by applying Ontario’s provincially legislated Fault Determination Rules, which outline how to assign fault in dozens of common accident scenarios. It is a standardized process, not an arbitrary decision.
What if I am hit by an uninsured driver?

If you are hit by a driver who is identified and confirmed to be uninsured, your damages would be covered under the mandatory Uninsured Automobile Coverage section of your policy, not DCPD. In Ontario, this coverage provides up to $25,000 for damages to your vehicle and its contents and is subject to a mandatory $300 deductible.

Why Trust carinsuranceinontario.ca?

Carinsuranceinontario.ca is a website maintained by a licensed Ontario insurance broker. It is a resource dedicated to providing information for Ontario drivers. Our goal is to empower you with the knowledge needed to make informed decisions about your insurance. The content on this website is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for a personal consultation with a licensed professional.

Take Action

Making decisions about your no-fault insurance Ontario coverage shouldn’t be left to chance. The rules are specific, and the right policy can be hard to find. To get an accurate quote and find a policy that truly fits your unique situation, you need a personalized assessment. Contact me today to get your free, no-obligation quote and a personalized review of your coverage options

Legal Disclaimer

This information is for educational purposes only and not professional advice. Insurance laws change, and individual needs vary. Always consult qualified professionals for personalized guidance. We are not liable for actions based on this content.

Peter Martire, (Chartered Insurance Professional), CRM, RIBO

Get Quotes

Contact: peter.martire@begininsurance.ca

Last updated: August 2025 | Ontario insurance regulations and rates subject to change