Does Car Insurance Cover Theft in Ontario? 2025 Guide
Yes, car insurance covers theft in Ontario if you have comprehensive, all-perils, or specified perils coverage. Liability-only policies do not protect against stolen vehicles. This complete guide explains coverage types, the claims process, and how to maximize your protection.
At a Glance: Ontario Car Theft Coverage
| Coverage Type | Protects Against Theft | Typical Deductible | Best For |
| Comprehensive | ✅ Vehicle + parts theft | $500-$1,000 | Most drivers |
| All-Perils | ✅ Broadest protection | $500-$1,000 | High-value vehicles |
| Specified Perils | ✅ Listed risks only | $500-$1,000 | Budget-conscious |
| Liability Only | ❌ No theft protection | N/A | Not recommended |
Key Facts You Need to Know
- Police report required – File within 24 hours of discovering theft
- 72-hour recovery period – Insurers wait before declaring total loss
- Claims settle in 2-4 weeks on average
- Personal items not covered – Use home/tenant insurance instead
- Ontario theft rates dropped 19% in early 2025, but Toronto/GTA remain hotspots
- High-theft vehicle surcharges range from $500-$2,500 annually
- Anti-theft devices can eliminate surcharges and reduce premiums
- Rental coverage available during claims process
What Types of Car Insurance Cover Theft in Ontario?
Three main coverage types protect Ontario drivers against vehicle theft. Understanding the differences helps you choose the right protection level for your needs.
Comprehensive Coverage
Best for: Most Ontario drivers seeking balanced protection
- Covers: Vehicle theft, stolen car parts, vandalism, fire, hail damage
- Deductible: Typically $500-$1,000
- Example: $20,000 stolen car with $500 deductible = $19,500 payout
All-Perils Coverage
Best for: High-value vehicles or maximum protection
- Covers: Broadest protection including collision + comprehensive
- Includes: Household/employee theft scenarios
- Deductible: Typically $500-$1,000
Specified Perils Coverage
Best for: Budget-conscious drivers with basic needs
- Covers: Only specifically listed risks (check your policy)
- Limitation: More restrictive than comprehensive
- Deductible: Typically $500-$1,000
Learn more about Ontario auto insurance coverage requirements
What Should I Do If My Car Gets Stolen in Ontario?
In the stressful event of a vehicle theft, knowing the correct steps to take can make a major difference in the outcome of your insurance claim. Following this essential process ensures a smooth and efficient stolen vehicle recovery and claim.
Step 1: Contact Police Immediately (Within Hours)
Call 911 or local police right away
- File official stolen vehicle report
- Get police report number (essential for insurance claim)
- Ask if your car was towed to impound lot
- Keep report number safe – you’ll need it multiple times
Step 2: Notify Your Insurance Company (Within 24 Hours)
Contact your insurer as soon as possible
Information to provide:
- Police report number from Step 1
- Vehicle identification (VIN, license plate, make/model)
- Theft circumstances and location
- Complete list of items inside vehicle
- Your contact information for adjuster
An adjuster will be assigned to manage your claim and guide you through the recovery process.
Step 3: Understand the 72-Hour Recovery Period
What happens: Insurers allow 72 hours before declaring total loss and starting payout process.
Why it matters: This gives police time to potentially recover your vehicle, avoiding a total loss on your record and allowing for repair instead of replacement.
Need Help Now? Emergency Checklist
- Call police (911 or local)
- Get police report number
- Call your insurance company
- Secure alternative transportation
- Gather vehicle documents
- List items that were in car
- Contact work/family about situation
How Long Does Insurance Take to Pay for a Stolen Vehicle?
Standard timeline: 2-4 weeks from claim initiation to settlement
Factors affecting payout speed:
- Adjuster workload and investigation complexity
- Whether vehicle is recovered within 72 hours
- Completeness of your documentation
- Cooperation with investigation process
If recovered within 72 hours: Repairs are covered instead of replacement, potentially saving you from a total loss claim on your record.
Rental Car Coverage During Theft Claims
When your vehicle is stolen, having access to a rental car can be a lifesaver. However, the coverage available to you depends on your specific policy and whether you have optional endorsements. Understanding your rental car options during a theft claim can save you significant inconvenience and out-of-pocket costs.
With OPCF 20 Transportation Replacement Coverage
Immediate access once your theft claim is authorized
- No waiting period
- Comprehensive rental coverage
- Higher daily limits
- Recommended for: Daily drivers who can’t afford transportation gaps
Learn more about OPCF 20 rental coverage options
Without OPCF 20
While this endorsement provides the most comprehensive benefit, the Ontario Automobile Policy (OAP 1) also offers some basic loss of use coverage as an additional benefit, but only for specific perils like theft:
Limited to $900 total and begins after 72-hour waiting period
- More restrictive but included with comprehensive/all-perils policies
- Covers basic transportation needs
- Suitable for: Drivers with alternative transportation options
Does Car Insurance Cover Stolen Car Parts?
Yes, with appropriate coverage (comprehensive, all-perils, specified perils)
Most Commonly Stolen Parts Covered:
- Catalytic converters (major theft target in Ontario)
- Wheels and tires
- Audio/electronics systems
- Airbags
- GPS navigation systems
- Attached equipment and modifications
Coverage example: $2,000 catalytic converter theft with $500 deductible = $1,500 insurance payout
All stolen parts coverage is subject to your deductible and requires comprehensive, all-perils, or specified perils protection.
What’s NOT Covered: Personal Items
Major misconception: Auto insurance does NOT cover personal belongings stolen from your vehicle
Not covered by car insurance:
- Electronics (phones, laptops, tablets)
- Clothing and personal effects
- Cash and wallets
- Tools and equipment
- Sports gear and recreational items
What covers personal items: Home or tenant insurance policies
Who Pays When Someone Crashes Your Stolen Car?
Your insurance company initially covers damages caused by someone driving your stolen vehicle in Ontario.
How it works:
- Your insurer pays for accident damages immediately
- They may attempt to recover costs from the thief
- Recovery is often unsuccessful due to criminal’s lack of assets
- You’re protected from liability in stolen vehicle accidents
- You will not be rated for the accident (but will show up on your insurance history)
Car Theft Prevention & Insurance Discounts
Proactive theft prevention not only protects your vehicle but can also lead to significant savings on your insurance premiums. Many Ontario insurers offer discounts for vehicles equipped with approved anti-theft devices, making a smart investment in security a financially sound decision.
Approved Anti-Theft Devices That Reduce Premiums:
- GPS tracking systems (Tag tracking, LoJack)
- Engine immobilizers (factory or aftermarket)
- Steering wheel locks (Club-style devices)
- Audible alarm systems
- Kill switches and other disabling devices
Prevention Tips:
- Park in secure, well-lit areas
- Never leave vehicle running unattended
- Don’t leave valuables visible
- Use multiple security layers
- Consider comprehensive coverage for high-theft areas
Money-saving opportunity: Many Ontario insurers offer discounts or waive high-theft surcharges for properly equipped vehicles. These discounts aren’t always available through direct sales.
Ontario Car Theft Statistics & High-Risk Vehicles (2025 Update)
Understanding current theft trends and knowing which vehicles are most often targeted can help you make informed decisions about your insurance coverage and prevention strategies. While recent data shows encouraging progress in fighting auto theft, it’s still a significant risk for many Ontario drivers.
Current Theft Trends
Positive news: Stolen vehicles declined 19% in early 2025 according to Ministry of Transportation Ontario data.
Persistent risks: Toronto and Greater Toronto Area (GTA) remain theft hotspots with organized crime targeting specific vehicle types.
High-Risk Vehicle Analysis
While official statistics provide a general overview, our team’s experience from handling thousands of claims over 20 years offers a deeper insight into specific theft patterns and the types of vehicles most frequently targeted by professional theft rings in Ontario.
Luxury SUV Professional Targeting:
- Lexus RX Series: Average theft time 45 seconds using signal amplifiers
- Range Rover Evoque: $3,200 average surcharge without approved tracking system
- BMW X5: Most stolen between 2-4 AM in Mississauga/Brampton corridors
“Everyday” Vehicle Export Theft:
- Honda CR-V (2017-2022): Targeted for overseas export, 72% recovery rate within 48 hours
- Toyota Highlander: $1,800 typical surcharge, waived with factory immobilizer + aftermarket GPS
- Ford F-150: Highest theft-to-claim-denial ratio due to key-related negligence disputes
Real Case Study – March 2025:
Client’s 2023 Lexus RX stolen from Oakville driveway using signal amplifier. Despite comprehensive coverage, the $2,500 high-theft surcharge made renewal unaffordable. We moved them to specialized insurer with approved tracking system discounts, reducing premium by $1,400 annually while maintaining full protection.
Insurance surcharges: $500-$2,500 annually, but approved anti-theft devices can eliminate these costs entirely.
Replacement Cost Insurance for Stolen Financed/Leased Vehicles
If your financed or leased vehicle is stolen, a standard insurance payout based on its depreciated value (Actual Cash Value) may not be enough to cover the remaining loan balance. This could leave you making payments on a car you no longer own. It’s crucial to understand the two main coverage options that protect you from this risk.
Replacement Cost Coverage (OPCF 43) vs. GAP Insurance
These two products are often confused but serve different purposes. In Ontario, OPCF 43 is the most common solution available from insurers.
- Replacement Cost Coverage (OPCF 43): This is an endorsement added to your auto insurance policy that protects the value of the vehicle. If your car is stolen, it ensures the insurer pays out the cost of a new vehicle of the same make and model, waiving any deduction for depreciation.
- GAP Insurance: This is a separate financial product, often sold by dealerships, that protects the loan balance. It covers the “gap” between what your standard insurance pays out for the settled value and what you still owe on your loan.
Why OPCF 43/43A Waiver of Depreciation is Essential
For drivers with new or recently purchased vehicles, OPCF 43 is the best way to secure your investment against a total loss due to theft.
- Waives Depreciation: It prevents the insurer from deducting depreciation from your claim payout, ensuring you get a settlement based on the full replacement cost.
- Provides Financial Freedom: This payout gives you the funds needed to replace your stolen vehicle, giving you the freedom to choose your next vehicle, not just to pay off debt.
- Protects Your Investment: Without this coverage, you could owe thousands more on a stolen car than your insurance settlement covers.
To protect yourself completely, OPCF 43 is the recommended solution to ensure you have the funds to pay off your loan and purchase a replacement vehicle.
Learn more about OPCF 43 coverage
Theft Situations Not Covered by Ontario Car Insurance
Some important exclusions that could leave you without coverage:
- Theft by household members living with you – (exempted with All Perils coverage)
- Theft by your employees – (exempted with All Perils coverage)
- Fraudulent or staged theft claims
- Material misrepresentation
- Statutory exclusions
These exclusions apply regardless of coverage type (comprehensive, all-perils, specified perils).
Coverage for Rental and Courtesy Vehicles
When driving borrowed or rented vehicles:
Coverage depends on:
- Rental company insurance (if you purchased coverage)
- Your own policy transfer (if coverage extends to rental)
- Owner’s insurance (if no transfer or purchase occurred)
Important: Standard deductibles and policy limits apply to stolen rental vehicle claims. Always clarify coverage before driving.
Frequently Asked Questions About Ontario Car Theft Insurance
These common questions help clarify the most confusing parts of car theft claims and coverage in Ontario. Understanding these scenarios before a theft occurs can help you act quickly and with confidence.
-
Does theft coverage apply if my car was unlocked or running?
Yes, your theft coverage will still apply in this situation. A common misconception is that leaving a vehicle unlocked or running automatically voids your insurance, but this is not the case. The purpose of insurance is to cover losses, including those that may result from simple negligence. While it’s always best to secure your vehicle to prevent theft, your claim would not typically be denied for this reason.
-
Can I claim vehicle theft under my home insurance?
No, vehicle theft must be claimed under auto insurance. Only personal items stolen from inside may be covered by home/tenant/condo insurance.
-
Does theft coverage work for leased or rental cars?
Yes, but coverage depends on the situation:
Leased Cars: Your personal auto policy covers a leased car just like a owned vehicle. However, the insurance payout for a stolen leased vehicle goes to the leasing company first to satisfy your loan obligations.
Rental Cars (Temporary Substitute): If you are in a claim situation (e.g., your personal car was just stolen) and need a rental car, that rental is considered a “temporary substitute vehicle.” It will be covered for theft and other perils just like your own car, provided you have the appropriate coverage on your policy.
Rental Cars (General Use): If you are renting a car for a vacation or business trip, theft coverage is not automatic. You will need to either have the OPCF 27 endorsement on your personal policy or purchase a Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver (LDW) directly from the rental car agency.
-
How does my deductible affect stolen car claims?
You pay your deductible amount and the insurer covers the remaining cost up to actual cash value or replacement cost for your stolen vehicle.
-
What documents do I need for my theft claim?
Required documentation:
– Police report and report number
– Vehicle registration and ownership
– Proof of insurance coverage
– Photos of vehicle (if available)
– List of items inside stolen car
– Keys (if you still have spares) -
What happens if my car is stolen from a garage or mechanic?
Coverage for theft typically applies in this situation. Your insurance policy is still in effect even if the car is in a mechanic’s custody.
In these scenarios, your insurance company would likely pay out the claim to you first. They would then handle the complex process of “subrogation,” which is when they investigate to see if the garage or mechanic was negligent. If negligence is found, your insurance company would then legally pursue the garage’s insurance to recoup the costs of your claim and, if successful, may even be able to recover your deductible for you.
Why Choose carinsuranceinontario.ca for Your Theft Protection?
Choosing the right insurance professional for your theft coverage is a critical decision. It’s not just about finding a policy; it’s about securing peace of mind and knowing you have an expert on your side if a theft occurs. Our unique approach delivers superior value for Ontario drivers seeking optimal theft protection.
Licensed Broker Advantage vs Insurance Agents
We work for you, not insurance companies
- Compare options from 17+ providers
- Find best theft protection and pricing, especially valuable for high-risk vehicle owners
- Independent advocacy during claims
Professional Credentials You Can Trust
RIBO-Licensed and FSRA-Regulated
- Highest professional standards
- Accountable to governing bodies
- Reliable advice backed by regulation
- Expert guidance on theft coverage nuances
Protect Your Vehicle Today
Don’t wait until it’s too late – ensure your Ontario vehicle has proper theft protection now. Every day without adequate coverage puts your investment at risk.
Take action now:
- Review your current coverage – Do you have comprehensive, all-perils, or specified perils?
- Consider anti-theft devices – Reduce premiums and improve protection
- Compare options – Different insurers offer varying theft protection benefits
- Get professional guidance – Licensed brokers ensure you have optimal coverage
Visit carinsuranceinontario.ca to compare auto theft insurance options, receive a personalized quote, and work with licensed brokers ready to guide you through comprehensive stolen vehicle protection.
References and Sources
- Ministry of Transportation Ontario (2025). Ontario Vehicle Theft Statistics Report. Data showing 19% decline in stolen vehicles during early 2025
- Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (2025). Ontario Auto Insurance Coverage Requirements. Official guidelines for comprehensive, all-perils, and specified perils coverage.
- Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (2025). Licensed Insurance Broker Standards. Professional standards for insurance brokers handling auto theft coverage.
Legal Disclaimer
This information is for educational purposes only and not professional advice. Insurance laws change, and individual needs vary. Always consult qualified professionals for personalized guidance. We are not liable for actions based on this content.
Peter Martire, (Chartered Insurance Professional), CRM, RIBO
Contact: peter.martire@begininsurance.ca
Last updated: August 2025 | Ontario insurance regulations and rates subject to change